Debate over Goodrich Ave rental underlines neighbors’ frustration with student housing

—

Appeals over a former single-family home on Goodrich Avenue have become the latest lightning rod for pushback on an influx of rental construction that St. Thomas’ neighbors have called “a wrecking ball for the neighborhood.”

The St. Paul City Council voted 5-1 Oct. 28 to deny an appeal that sought to revoke approval for the rental property planned for 2094 Goodrich Ave., which sits roughly four blocks south of McNeely Hall and two blocks east of South Field. 

The appellant, neighboring resident Joe Gallante, made his case to the board, supported by 18 residents who spoke against the proposed development. In total, over 30 supporters left the meeting, some shouting angrily, after the votes were cast.

“This makes me question if there is good governance (in St. Paul),” resident John Halla said. “Your obligation as elected officials is to have our backs, not the back of a developer.”

Ward 4 Councilmember Molly Coleman, whose ward includes the property in question, said that she voted to reject the appeal because the planned 9,300 square-foot, 18-resident development was found to be compliant with St. Paul zoning law and said that changing established policy was not on the table.

“When we sit here looking at this specific appeal, the question is not ‘What do we want the law to be?’ or ‘What do we want the zoning code to say?’” Coleman said. 

Zoning changes implemented in 2023 to increase housing density in St. Paul allowed for the creation of duplexes and triplexes in formerly single-family-only blocks, including a slew of new rental properties built in the neighborhood surrounding St. Thomas. The 2094 Goodrich Ave. development is zoned as a triplex, consisting of three units that house six residents each, the maximum allowed in a single unit. 

Gallante said that the high number of actual occupants in the rental, paired with the planned fourth-floor common area and roof deck that total 2,484 square feet, means that the development should have been zoned differently.

“A 2,400-square-foot gathering space is not incidental, nor customary to a typical triplex, and it makes this something more than a development with three dwelling units,” Gallante said. 

Resident Jane Rauenhorst, who owns a triplex in the area, said Wednesday that the number of residents living in developments like the one planned at 2094 Goodrich is egregious and accused some new triplexes of renting each unit’s beds separately, which is prohibited. 

“I own a triplex, six bedrooms, four bathrooms, up to six residents,” Rauenhorst said. “These places are rented by the bed; not by the unit, by the bed, at $900 a month.” 

Coleman said that if the property owner was found to be renting out rooms individually rather than each six-room unit as a package, the property would lose its rental status. She said the city is aware of concerns over spaces being rented as single-room occupancies and that such concerns are “being pursued actively.”

Attorney Adam Niblick, who represented 2094 Goodrich property owner Eric Vogstrom at the meeting, said that the project’s design “conforms strictly” with existing law. 

“What the appellant and others opposing this project are asking with this appeal is the imposition of rules and regulations that simply don’t apply to this project,” Niblick said.

Meanwhile, many neighbors argued that the plans betray the spirit of the zoning code and would contribute to a problem that has already overwhelmed some nearby streets. Portland Avenue resident Danielle Hokanson said issues related to student presence in the neighborhood are “an accident waiting to happen.”

“We have safety issues; the crosswalks are blocked every single day. Elderly people have to make their way around that,” Hokanson said. “ … We have the stop sign in front of my house; it is run all day, every single day. This is not a student problem, this is a density problem.”  

Other concerns included the long-term safety and stability of what residents said are often quickly and cheaply-constructed rental developments. 

Goodrich resident Drake Lightner said he is afraid that when the University of St. Thomas eventually builds more housing to meet student demand, many of the new rentals will go vacant because they are unsuitable to anyone but students. St. Thomas is currently in the process of negotiating with neighbors to develop new residential space on its Mid-Campus, which would add around 500 on-campus beds.

The prevailing theme among residents who spoke was their surprise over how much the character of their neighborhood has changed — and how quickly. 

“This building type now, it’s almost to Ford Parkway; it’s spreading like wildfire,” resident Gary Johnson said. “ … If the desire is just to make St. Paul, you know, all rental housing, then I guess you might as well just let things go.” 

Johnson, a local architect, said he felt the decision to change the zoning code in 2023 was “tremendously flawed” and that the issue should be put to St. Paul voters in a referendum, which was met with applause from audience members.

Councilmember Anika Bowie, who represents Ward 1, was the sole dissenting vote on the appeal and said she would have preferred more legal information before denying the appeal. Council president Rebecca Noecker, who represents Ward 2, said that the issue in this case came down solely to whether the proposed development is technically considered a triplex.

“We have to apply the law as it is,” Noecker said. “Testimony like this can also cause us to question the laws as they are and make new laws, and we can do that. We can’t do that in the middle of the game.” 

The council’s decision means that Vogstrom can continue plans to build on the property, approval for which will expire in May 2027, according to city records. 

Kevin Lynch can be reached at lync1832@stthomas.edu.

,
KUST Radio is on Mixlr

The Crest
The Crest
The News Brief- November 14th
Loading
/

The Crest
The Crest
The News Brief
Loading
/

The Crest
The Crest
What’s Up With
Loading
/

The Crest
The Crest
The News Brief- October 17th
Loading
/

The Crest
The Crest
PODCAST: The News Brief- April 16th
Loading
/

View this profile on Instagram

The Crest (@thecrestnews) • Instagram photos and videos